2021.09.19 19:46 Gloomy-Conflict-7308 Critique of marxian view of human nature
I have a question pertaining to Marxian view of humans are defined by their "production relations" and material conditions, the fact that the "form of [social/humna] intercourse is determined by production," that "The nature of individuals thus depends on the material conditions determining their production." He also mentioend something like it in the theses: ""But the human essence is no abstraction inherent in each single individual. In its reality it is the ensemble of the social relations."
Also, more specifically in Capital -- " But here individuals are dealt with only in so far as they are the personifications of economic categories, embodiments of particular class-relations and class-interests. My standpoint, from which the evolution of the economic formation of society is viewed as a process of natural history, can less than any other make the individual responsible for relations whose creature he socially remains, however much he may subjectively raise himself above them."
Also touched on in this passage of the manifesto which I find to be quite lacking overall, even in the full context of the passage:
" “There are, besides, eternal truths, such as Freedom, Justice, etc., that are common to all states of society. But Communism abolishes eternal truths, it abolishes all religion, and all morality, instead of constituting them on a new basis; it therefore acts in contradiction to all past historical experience.”
What does this accusation reduce itself to? The history of all past society has consisted in the development of class antagonisms, antagonisms that assumed different forms at different epochs[...]"
Now, I'm only reffering to it as a theory of human nature because I don't know a better statement for this group of beliefs, outside of his particular brand of materialism.
I'm looking for philosophical critiques of these statments, and, also, philosphers(economists and sociologists as well) who have specifically critized this, specifically the fact of essence -- and that humans and ideas don't have a particular "eternal" essence except relatives histroical whims. I'd like to hear the philosophical criticism for this.
submitted by Gloomy-Conflict-7308 to askphilosophy [link] [comments]
2021.09.19 19:46 Kujar3 GCG Reddit just teased summer Juno. Swimsuit banner 99% next in line.
|submitted by Kujar3 to GirlCafeGun [link] [comments]|
2021.09.19 19:46 Success_Complex Anyone know about the e learnings you can do to become a shift lead/key holder?
2021.09.19 19:46 CJyouasshole hrrm
2021.09.19 19:46 MrWilson420 Always rewinding on xbox
2021.09.19 19:46 NexusEvo Throwing the goodies at the new build. 2.0lr
|submitted by NexusEvo to MitsubishiEvolution [link] [comments]|
2021.09.19 19:46 -AfroSamurai Splitscreen?
2021.09.19 19:46 SetsunaAndDiana Arbalest x Musketeer propaganda lets go!
|submitted by SetsunaAndDiana to darkestdungeon [link] [comments]|
2021.09.19 19:46 martijnb16 Oh god this is it.. The end of the world is apon us.
|submitted by martijnb16 to pokemongo [link] [comments]|
2021.09.19 19:46 johnrock001 Most Popular Brown Haired Anime Boys - Anime Boy
Most Popular Brown Haired Anime Boys - Anime Boy - https://www.myanimeforlife.com/brown-haired-anime-boy/
submitted by johnrock001 to myanimeforlife [link] [comments]
2021.09.19 19:46 Zdawg_613 My mom caught the perfect blop
|submitted by Zdawg_613 to blop [link] [comments]|
2021.09.19 19:46 WinnieEats Is this the work of this subreddit ?
|submitted by WinnieEats to MilenaCiciottiSnark2 [link] [comments]|
2021.09.19 19:46 SnooTangerines3226 flag of Brazil but just the states I like
|submitted by SnooTangerines3226 to vexillologycirclejerk [link] [comments]|
2021.09.19 19:46 WTZWBlaze A subreddit for when people link a subreddit but use an uppercase R
2021.09.19 19:46 HiAttila My shot at naming EVERY SINGLE PROTAGONIST IN ALL OF DANGANRONPA FRANCHISE
>Shuichi >Makoto >Hajime >Nagito >Yasuhiro >Kanon >Komaru >Toko >Syo >Ryoko >Yasuke >Takumi >Chiaki >Kazuichi >Misaki >Kohei >Byakuya >Yui >Kyoko >Mikan >Shinobu >Kaede >Mukuro Did i missed anyone?
submitted by HiAttila to danganronpa [link] [comments]
2021.09.19 19:46 AustinIsReallyCool 30752
|submitted by AustinIsReallyCool to CountOnceADay [link] [comments]|
2021.09.19 19:46 unwantedhated Can someone be a better person?
Let’s so you get irritated easily but you have a job that requires you to be friendly.Would that help you be more friendly?I know you have to want to change but was just wondering if it’ possible
submitted by unwantedhated to polls [link] [comments]
2021.09.19 19:46 killrtaco Black strap starting to flower and showing its purple!
|submitted by killrtaco to MultiVerseBeans [link] [comments]|
2021.09.19 19:46 Apart_Home5936 Here is the trailer for a VR game my brother and I are developing. What you think?
|submitted by Apart_Home5936 to oculus [link] [comments]|
2021.09.19 19:46 just_some__guy_ This girl is driving me insane :D
She asked me out and i said yes cause i liked her for a long time and then the following day out of the blue she said she wants to keep being friends. I was so happy when she asked me out and now its just awkward and we dont really talk. How do we go back to being the really close friends we were? I miss her and i hope we can give a relationship another shot someday but for now i want to go back to being good friends. Any responses are greatly appreciated
submitted by just_some__guy_ to Advice [link] [comments]
2021.09.19 19:46 The_Shook_Mulberry Tier List on What Selena Thinks of Other Heroes
|submitted by The_Shook_Mulberry to MobileLegendsGame [link] [comments]|
2021.09.19 19:46 Primary_Shine116 Not even the younglings survived
|submitted by Primary_Shine116 to PrequelMemes [link] [comments]|
2021.09.19 19:46 ThatOneBryce Small detail from ALL EYES ON ME…
2021.09.19 19:46 LemonKigu [OC] You're really walking home this late... alone?
|submitted by LemonKigu to comics [link] [comments]|
2021.09.19 19:46 JuanSimmons8655 RCPlanes..............RC Plane Remote Radio Control Controlled Gift......RC Plane
|submitted by JuanSimmons8655 to RCPlanes [link] [comments]|